Are you considering organic herbicides? - Weedtechnics

Are you considering organic herbicides?

Jeremy Winer

As environmental awareness grows, many gardeners and agricultural professionals seek sustainable solutions for weed control. However, the effectiveness of organic herbicides often raises questions. Jeremy Winer, Managing Director of Weedtechnics, shares valuable insights on this topic, highlighting the potential of innovative alternatives like Satusteam.

Do Organic Herbicides Work?

Organic herbicides can be effective, but their success hinges on several factors, including the type of weed, application conditions, and formulation. According to Jeremy, organic herbicides typically work by burning or dehydrating plant tissue. They are generally more effective on young, small weeds with soft leaves but struggle against established weeds with deeper root systems. Many users find that the burn-down effect lasts only 7 to 21 days, necessitating frequent reapplications throughout the growing season.

Are There Any Organic Pre-emergents to Control Weeds?

Yes, there are organic pre-emergent options available, such as corn gluten meal. These products aim to prevent weed seeds from germinating. However, their effectiveness can vary significantly based on environmental conditions. Timing is crucial, as organic pre-emergents must be applied strategically to coincide with weed seed germination, often requiring multiple applications for optimal results. 

Do Environmentally Friendly Weed Killers Exist?

Absolutely! Environmentally friendly weed killers are available, ranging from manual labor, which is labor-intensive yet sustainable, to products like vinegar, citrus-based oils, and non-ionic herbicides. While these options are marketed as eco-friendly, they often demand frequent applications and may not match the effectiveness of traditional chemical herbicides, particularly against larger, established weeds.

Is Slasher as Effective as They Claim?

Slasher, an organic herbicide made from plant-derived non-ionic acids, can offer some effectiveness on young weeds but often requires multiple applications for consistent control. Jeremy emphasizes that like many organic herbicides, Slasher may not provide lasting control without repeated treatments, especially in challenging conditions.Slasher reviews slasher review

Why Do Manufacturers Claim Organic Herbicides Are So Expensive?

The high cost of organic herbicides is primarily due to the sourcing and processing of natural ingredients, which tends to be more expensive than synthetic alternatives. Additionally, organic herbicides generally require more frequent applications and higher volumes to achieve results comparable to chemical herbicides, leading to increased overall costs for both the product and labor.

Is SatusteamTM More Affordable Than Organic Herbicides for Horticultural Purposes?

In many cases, yes. Jeremy notes that customers transitioning from organic herbicides like Slasher to Satusteam often experience a significant reduction in costs. This is because organic herbicides typically necessitate multiple applications throughout the season, particularly to manage new weed growth or perennial weeds, resulting in higher material and labor expenses. Conversely, SatusteamTM provides longer-lasting control—up to 1.5 to 2 times longer than comparable eco-sprays—thereby reducing the frequency of applications and overall costs.

Organic herbicides all work if you have enough volume and concentration to directly contact the weeds.  However, these herbicides are expensive and may not be affordable for commercial crop production at this time.

Compare Treatment Rates of Satusteam to Organic Herbicides

Satusteam offers enhanced efficiency by penetrating the top layer of soil, effectively destroying weed seeds and reducing the need for frequent treatments. While organic herbicides may require reapplication every 14 to 21 days, SatusteamTM allows for longer intervals between treatments, drastically lowering overall treatment frequency and associated costs.

Why Might SatusteamTM Be Better Than Organic Herbicides in a Commercial Setting, Such as an Organic Farm?

For commercial settings, particularly organic farms, SatusteamTM presents numerous advantages. It effectively manages a broader range of weeds under various climatic conditions and is particularly effective against larger, deep-rooted weeds. Although there is an upfront investment in the equipment, SatusteamTM reduces labor costs and enhances efficiency over time. Its ability to manage the seed bank means fewer weeds and less competition for crops, making it a more sustainable and cost-effective solution for organic farmers. Check out all the benefits of SatusteamTM here. 

Conclusion

While organic herbicides serve a purpose in weed management, they may not be the most cost-effective or long-lasting solution available. Innovative alternatives like Satusteam offer a sustainable and economical approach to effective weed control. As Jeremy Winer emphasizes, for those seeking reliable, long-term solutions in organic farming and horticulture, investing in advanced methods such as Satusteam can yield superior results compared to traditional organic herbicides.

 

About the Author : Jeremy Winer

Jeremy Winer has 30 years of practical experience in implementing integrated holistic approach to organic weed management across urban landscapes, recreational parklands and wetlands. He currently runs Weedtechnics specialising in providing chemical reduction and non-toxic weed control programs to municipalities across Australia. He has developed, patented, manufactured, and commercialised the Steamwand method of creating saturated steam for vegetation control.